chronicle duke university
chronicle duke university
chronicle duke university
A Federal Match Makes College More Affordable For Scholarship Students
As 2007 drew to a close, four of the nation’s most selective colleges: Harvard, Duke, Swarthmore and Pomona, all announced plans to revamp their financial aid policies by replacing loans with grants. Other institutions, most notably Princeton and Columbia, had already implemented similar plans.
Harvard’s policy is novel; according to the chronicle of higher education, the university announced that families with incomes between $120,000 and $180,000 would be asked to contribute no more than 10 percent of their student’s total expenses for college, while the neediest families would pay nothing. Harvard will raise its student financial aid budget by $22 million to implement this policy. With a $35 billion endowment, highest in the nation, Harvard can afford to do it; the added monies for aid are just a drop in the bucket.
This is good news for anyone wishing to apply to Harvard; cost is less of a detriment to well-qualified candidates in upper middle class families. A $180,000 family income gets spread awfully thin when there’s more than one child in college and the family lives in a high-cost metro area. But if cost is less of a detriment to going to Harvard, than Harvard will become more selective, because the number of applications will surely rise.
This has a ripple effect, students apply to more colleges, so they’re sure they will be admitted somewhere; other institutions become more selective too. Few can afford to do what Harvard has done. Imagine the resentment in a household where a Harvard reject must attend their safety school – and must pay more than they would have paid to go to Harvard, even if the safety school is their state university.
It’s difficult to pity families in this predicament; the parents earn a good income and their child has not wanted for much, until this point. There are small tax credits; the Hope Tax Credit allows a deduction of $1,650 per student for the first two years of college, and the Life Long Learning Tax Credit may cover up to $2,000 of tuition for the remaining years. The cap on family income for these credits is $114,000.
The relief is paltry when I consider that Rutgers, my home state university, costs $20,000 for tuition, fees, room and board for an in-state student. It’s reasonable to expect the entering freshmen and their parents to spend $100,000 for a bachelor’s degree after four years, and certainly after five.
Government loans can’t cover the total cost of a Rutgers degree; the maximum undergraduates may borrow ranges from $7,500 to $10,500 – and that’s for a combination of interest-subsidized and unsubsidized loans. The maximum they may borrow for four years is $37,000; this principal is unlikely to rise as fast as Rutgers’ tuition.
The federal government allows borrowers to consolidate those loans and repay them over 20 years; our $37,000 borrower repays $295 a month.
Assuming they qualified; there are needs tests associated with these loans.
Assuming they have no other loans at higher interest rates; the interest on interest – subsidized loans is 6.8 percent, and 7.9 percent for unsubsidized loans. Lord help any college student or parent who pays more principal and interest on student loans; it’s not worth it.
So what’s a family to do, if federal loans can’t cover the difference between their resources and the total cost of college?
I guess they could hope their child gets into Harvard, or its kin.
Or they could hope that colleges loosen their purse strings; according to the National Association of College and University Business Administrators, the average institution spends only 4.6 percent of their endowment. The approach of Congress and the Bush Administration has been to slap colleges on the wrist and tell them to or loosen purse strings so that financial aid spending can be cut. The finger pointing is useless; the colleges have little to no incentive to cooperate.
The way I see it, we need an incentive to encourage schools to make more scholarship aid available, to encourage students and parents to become more financially prudent, and encourage students to do their best in the classroom. Grades are still important interview selection criteria; recruiters ask career centers to filter resumes by GPA before they see them.
Therefore, I propose a new incentive that I call the Federal Scholarship Match.
It works like this: for every dollar, up to $7,500, earned through an academic or service scholarship, the federal government would match it, up to the total cost of tuition, fees, room and board. This would not preclude a student from receiving other assistance; if the match doesn’t meet the total financial need, the student can receive loans or other aid.
Thus, for example, a bright student who receives a $3,000 scholarship to Rutgers (from any source other than the federal government: private, state, the school) would receive an additional $3,000. If he received a full-tuition ($8,500 today) scholarship, he’d receive an additional $7,500 in federal match, so he and his family would be responsible for the balance, or $4,000.
The family with the six-figure income could pay the $4,000 out of their pocket – or the student could earn it through employment.
I can just see the head spins and eye rolls in some quarters of the higher education community; this proposal redefines the idea of need-based aid. This is what I’d hear: The match puts the needs of the brightest, regardless of income, over the truly needy. It would also reduce the number of full-ride scholarships offered out of college coffers because the government would chip in.
I disagree with the first point; if a student was motivated enough to earn a scholarship, they deserve the opportunity to go to college. They also deserve to stay, if they were motivated enough to maintain the grades to keep it.
The second point is true, but colleges could offer an affordable education to more students. The matching program needs a catch: colleges must loosen their purse strings to qualify for the match and agree to aid more students.
In effect, the federal government would give every college the incentive to follow Harvard’s lead.
Who knows: a success match program could encourage Congress to offer young taxpayers a tax credit to help sustain it; thankful recipients could apply some of the money that they might be applying to student loan debt.
And they’d help future generations, including their children, pay for college.
About the Author
Stuart Nachbar has been involved with education politics, policy and technology as a student, urban planner, government affairs manager, software executive, and now as author of The Sex Ed Chronicles. Visit his blog,
Educated Quest
4/1/10 Interview with Pharrell
|
|
iHome iP43LVC Dual Alarm Clock Radio for your iPod/iPhone with Pillow Shaker (Blue) $75.95 Sla 12v 18ahupg 85977/d5745 sealed lead acid batteries (12v; 18 ah; ub12180). Specs: used in ups backup systems, spotlights, flashlights, exit lighting & other equipment; 12v; 18 ah; ub12180. Refurb: n. Returnable: y. Warranty: one year……. |
|
|
Dual Alrm Clck Rad Iphone/ipod Purple Charge Play Or Wake $91.77 iHome IP43UV Desktop Clock Radio IP43UV Clocks… |
|
|
Alex Super Baking set – 18 Piece Metal and Plastic Set $16.99 Measure, mix, prep, and bake some imaginary treats| This 18-piece set features a loaf pan, bear pan, heart pan, mixing bowl, rolling pin, whisk, measuring spoons and cup, pastry wheel, 2 star cookie cutters, 2 heart cookie cutter, and an oven mitt. Bon Appetit|… |
|
|
Passion of the Christ: Songs (Original Songs Inspired by the Film) $7.00 … |
|
|
Egyptian Hieroglyphs Made Easy $26.50 Learning and understanding of the ancient Egyptian hieroglyphic language. The hieroglyphic script was the longest lived and earliest form of the Egyptian language. Its use was limited primarily to religious and monumental inscriptions, whereas a more cursive script called hieratic was preferred for administrative and epistolary purposes. Hieroglyphic Egyptian employs pictures of objects, each with… |
|
|
Promised Land [CD-ROM] Queensryche’s follow-up to the double-platinum Empire is something of an acquired taste, but it’s well worth the effort. There’s considerable variety here; the heavy progressive-rock of “I Am I” and the ballad “Bridge” were hit singles, but there’s also the funk-inflected “Disconnected”, the edgy, spooky “Lady Jane”, and the piano-and-vocals “Someone Else?”. The title track is probably the stronge… |
|
|
Swirly Tree 3 – Vinyl Wall Decals Murals Stickers Art Graphic – 45H x56W – by üBer Decals Better than wallpaper, wall stickers are a perfect way to decorate your room and express yourself. They are a fun, easy and removable decor solution. These stickers are pre-cut and will only take you several minutes to apply on any surface – walls, doors, windows, and more. Each of our designs come with easy instructions to follow. This is an original design from uBer Decals. All other sellers are… |
|
|
Modern Floral Bird – Vinyl Wall Decals Murals Stickers Art Graphic – 46H x29W – by üBer Decals Better than wallpaper, wall stickers are a perfect way to decorate your room and express yourself. They are a fun, easy and removable decor solution. These stickers are pre-cut and will only take you several minutes to apply on any surface – walls, doors, windows, and more. Each of our designs come with easy instructions to follow. This is an original design from uBer Decals. All other sellers are… |
|
|
Yoga Girl – Vinyl Wall Decals Murals Stickers Art Graphic – 25H x 35W – by üBer Decals Better than wallpaper, wall stickers are a perfect way to decorate your room and express yourself. They are a fun, easy and removable decor solution. These stickers are pre-cut and will only take you several minutes to apply on any surface – walls, doors, windows, and more. Each of our designs come with easy instructions to follow. This is an original design from uBer Decals. All other sellers are… |
|
|
Shawn Interrupted $1.99 … |
|
|
Defending Polygamy $1.99 … |
|
|
America’s Funniest Home Videos: Sports Spectacular $3.26 AMERICA’S FUNNIEST HOME VIDEOS:SPORT – DVD Movie… |
|
|
Omaha Steaks Prime Rib Roasts Prime Rib Roasts… |
|
|
KIKE CALVO photo illustrations FREAKLANCES Collection – Freaklance Fausto with bike graphic tablet and keyword – Coffee Gift Baskets – Coffee Gift Basket $44.99 Freaklance Fausto with bike graphic tablet and keyword Coffee Gift Basket is measuring 9x9x4. Contains 15oz mug, BONUS free set of 4 coasters, biscotti and 5 blends of gourmet coffee. French Vanilla, Kenya AA, Decaf Colombian Supremo, Chocolate and Italian Roast Espresso elegantly presented in our signature black planet coffee gift box. A very nice and thoughtful gift for any occasion…. |
|
|
Betty Lous Organic Harmony Hippy Happy Apple Bar Case Pack 24 – 683021 $116.33 1.75 oz bar. Vegan. USDA organic. Ingredients: organic apple cinnamon granola [organic oats, organic maple syrup, organic oat flour, organic crisped rice (organic brown rice, malt syrup - GF, sea salt), organic brown rice syrup, organic walnuts, organic sunflower seeds, organic expeller pressed high oleic sunflower oil, organic unsulfured dried apples, organic cinnamon, organic vanilla, sea salt],… |
|
|
Sony ICF-C05iP Clock Radio for iPod (Black) $39.95 With the Sony ICFC05iPBLK Clock Radio you can charge your iPod’s battery while you sleep. This Sony ICFC05iPBLK Clock Radio is the space-saving bedside accessory for iPod® and iPhone® users. Set the alarm to wake to the radio, iPod®, or a buzzer. The charging tray ensures both you and your iPod/iPhone® start the day with a fully charged battery. Plus, The Sony ICFC05iPBLK Clock Radio features … |
|
|
Kuzy® – AQUA BLUE Keyboard Silicone Cover Skin for Macbook / Macbook Pro 13 15 17 Aluminum Unibody $0.99 Dress up your MacBook Pro in fashionable color, silicone protection now. *** Will Not fit MacBook Air 11″ ***… |
|
|
Sharp LC60LE835U Quattron 60-inch 1080p 240 Hz 3D LED-LCD HDTV, Black Sharp AQUOS LC-60LE835U 60″ 3D LCD TV LC-60LE835U LCD Flat Panel TVs… |
|
|
Tiger Balm Analgesic Tiger Muscle Rub … |
|
|
Gecko Nasal Pad – Large, 4.12 Long $24.80 The Gecko Nasal Pad (formerly the Sleep Comfort Care Pad by Sequal) is intended for patients with Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA) who experience pain and discomfort on or around the bridge of their nose associated with using nasal or full face masks. The pad acts as a cushion between the patient’s face and mask, and is simply placed across the bridge of the nose under the mask. The protective polyme… |
|
|
Pureology Hydrate Conditioner 8.5 oz. $21.95 You can feel this premium conditioner working to moisturize, detangle and lock in colour. Multiweight Protein Complex, jojoba and shea butter impart excellent lubricity and liveliness to your hair. Contains an invigorating infusion of peppermint oils…. |
|
|
Star Wars: Lost Tribe of the Sith #2: Skyborn $1.00 Don’t miss Star Wars: Lost Tribe of The Sith: Skyborn a FREE original eBook short story, the second in a series that tell the untold story of the Fate of the Jedi’s forgotten Sith castaways, their battle to survive, and their quest to re-conquer the galaxy! DECEIVE AND CONQUER A Jedi ambush leaves the Sith ship Omen marooned on a remo… |
|
|
Serial $1.00 Remember the twin golden rules of hitchhiking? # 1: Don’t go hitchhiking, because the driver who picks you up could be certifiably crazy. # 2: Don’t pick up hitchhikers, because the traveler you pick up could be raving nutcase. So what if, on some dark, isolated road, Crazy #1 offered a ride to Nutcase #2? When two of the most twisted minds in the world of horror fiction face off, the result is SE… |
|
|
The Wild’s Call $1.99 It is seven years after the collapse of modern civilization, and the world is entering a new Dark Age. Can best friends Elysia and Darien trust the animal spirits that are beckoning them to escape into the wilderness and create a new way of life? And will they give in to the mutual passion they’ve always denied?Don’t miss this thrilling prequel story set in the same world as Jeri Smith-Ready’s Asp… |
|
|
Rocket Dog Women’s Memories Ballet Flat $39.95 Create new casual day memories with this flirty and modern ballerina flat featuring a step-in and go design, thai silk detailing and ruched round toe with bow accent. By Rocket Dog Product Information • Heel Height – Flat • Material – Thai Silk • Toe – Round Final sale, no exchanges, no returns. CALIFORNIA PROP 65 WARNING: Bakers strives to provide safe and environmentally friendl… |
|
|
New Balance Women’s CW 442 Sneaker • A classic running shoe with gotta-have style • Low-profile synthetic upper • Cheery polka-dot lining • Cushy foam insole • Flexible rubber sole • Thick padding at collar and tongue… |
|
|
Stacy Adams Men’s Sabola Slip-On $85.00 Sizzling designer style is yours when you step into Sabola Tasseled Loafers from famous Stacy Adams! SAVE BIG! Put your best foot forward! Stacy Adams has built a 135-year reputation of excellence in fashion-forward footwear, and sharp Shoes like these leather-lined Loafers are a big part of the reason why! Each comfy pair has a genuine snakeskin toe box with crocodile-print leather uppers. The cu… |
|
|
Kuzy – PURPLE Keyboard Silicone Cover Skin for Macbook / Macbook Pro 13 15 17 Aluminum Unibody $2.00 Dress up your MacBook Pro in fashionable color, silicone protection now. *** Will Not fit MacBook Air 11″ ***… |
|
|
Kuzy – Circles Blue/White Keyboard Silicone Cover Skin for Macbook / Macbook Pro 13 15 17 Aluminum Unibody $9.95 Dress up your MacBook Pro in fashionable color, silicone protection now. *** Will Not fit MacBook Air 11″ ***… |
|
|
Maidenform Lilyette® Absolute Solution Lightly Lined Bra $34.00 Lilyette® has designed a bra that delivers the absolute solution for a full figure woman into one pad! Our Lilyette® Absolute Solution Lightly Lined Bra is the single bra that will supply you with modesty, lift, and shape!3 section cup each with a different benefit: Lift, Modesty and ShapingOffers full supportSoft fabricationPads are designed to leave you feeling confident and comfortableDeliv… |
Tags: duke, education, iphone, news, the chronicle duke university, university
Leave a Comment